You are here
Home > Arts & Entertainment > ‘Heartbeat of Wounded Knee’ enjoys early acclaim

‘Heartbeat of Wounded Knee’ enjoys early acclaim

A new book published in late January about Native American life has gotten a broad and healthy dose of early positive reviews.

“The Heartbeat of Wounded Knee: Native America from 1890 to the Present” is the latest work by David Treuer (Leech Lake Ojibwe), a professor of literature at the University of Southern California.

The book is described as a different way to look at and think of Native American history; a surprising, exciting and hopeful take on modern Native Americans.

If part of the title reminds you of another book, that’s not by accident. Treuer’s 528-page tome is supposed to act as a bit of an alternative to the seminal 1970 work of author Dee Brown: “Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee: An Indian History of the American West.” Brown’s book looks largely at the devastating effects of relentless warfare against Natives and their forced relocation during American expansionism.

The New Yorker calls Treuer’s book “A rebellious new history of Native American life,” and the New York Times: “A new history of Native Americans responds to ‘Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee.’”

“The book is about Native American life – what we’ve been up to since we were to have all died off in 1890 after Wounded Knee and the close of the frontier,” Treuer said in an email to the Seminole Tribune. “I really wanted to dispel the myth (held by us and by outsiders) that all we’ve done is live in a perpetual state of suffering – in America, but not of it; outside of history, (more or less as ghosts).”

Treuer said that history often acts as only a record of what’s been done to Native Americans. He wanted to show, to prove, that Natives have been making history, too.

“That we have been historical actors in our own lives,” he said.

Treuer’s been somewhat critical of certain work that he has previously described as “the precious way that Indians are portrayed in even the most well-meaning books and movies” – citing notable works from authors like Sherman Alexie (“The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven,” adapted into the movie “Smoke Signals”) and Louise Erdrich (“The Plague of Doves”).

David Treuer is the author of ‘Heartbeat of Wounded Knee.’ (Courtesy photo)

He said too often such work perpetuates stereotypes and misrepresents historic culture.

And, again, he pushes back on the way Native American history tends to be framed only through tragedy and loss.

“Since this book is about Native American life rather than Native American death, I needed to go back to the written record and recover a better version of the past,” Treuer said. “To go out and talk to Native folk all over the country to hear from them what their lives are like.”

Treuer said he doesn’t think of history in the past, but as living inside people and continuing to act through them.
“I needed to look at myself, my own life. It wouldn’t be fair to ask people to talk about themselves, to risk it, without asking the same of myself,” he said.

Treuer wants people to buy his book not as a public service to Natives, but to truly learn about the country because he says, “You can’t understand America unless you understand Native Americans.”

Treuer has published novels (his first “Little” in 1995) and nonfiction work, which includes 2012s “Rez Life: An Indian’s Journey Through Reservation Life.”

“Heartbeat” is his seventh major published work.

Damon Scott
Damon is a multimedia journalist for the Seminole Tribune. He has previously been an editor and reporter for digital and print media in Florida and his home state of New Mexico. Send him an email at

Leave a Reply